- Card Name
- Nightmare
- Current Price
- $1.14
- Price Range
- $1.08 – $1.20
- Set
- Fifth Edition
- Game
- Magic: The Gathering
- Rarity
- Rare
- Era
- Modern
- Type
- Normal
- Volatility
- Stable
- Last Updated
- June 30, 2026
| Period | Change |
|---|---|
| 30d | -17.6% |
| 90d | -62.7% |
Raw & Graded Price Snapshot
| Condition / Grade | Price | 7d | 30d | Recent Sales |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Raw / Ungraded | $1.14 | 0.0% | -17.6% | N/A |
Marketplace Price Comparison
| Source | Price | Basis | Action |
|---|---|---|---|
| Guardian Estimate | $1.14 | Blended market value | View price history |
| TCGPlayer | $1.19 | Marketplace price | Check listings |
Sources tracked: tcgplayer_market.
How Guardian Calculates This Price
Guardian combines marketplace prices, recent sold listings, graded-card estimates, and cross-market checks into one daily card value. We separate raw and graded prices where data is available, ignore obvious outliers, and update card pages as new market data arrives.
Track, Grade, or Sell This Card
- Add this card to your collection to track value over time.
- Check grading ROI before submitting to PSA, BGS, or CGC.
- Compare selling options for Magic: The Gathering cards.
- Scan another card for instant identification and pricing.
Track Nightmare price trends, view grading values, and get market alerts on Guardian TCG. Updated daily with data from multiple sources.
More Cards from Fifth Edition
Mana Vault — $92.02
Fifth Edition - Two-Player Starter Set — $89.99
Sylvan Library — $28.09
Necropotence — $27.35
Necropotence — $25.63
City of Brass — $24.24
Ashnod's Altar — $20.97
Birds of Paradise — $13.63
Armageddon — $12.85
Dark Ritual — $12.50
Nightmare in Other Sets
- Nightmare (Magic Alpha) — $987.66
- Nightmare (Magic Beta) — $429.63
Nightmare (Beta Edition) — $299.99- Nightmare (Beta Edition) — $299.99
- Nightmare (Magic 30th Anniversary) — $103.75
Nightmare (7th Edition) — $87.69
Nightmare (30th Anniversary Edition) — $34.49
Nightmare (Unlimited Edition) — $31.21- Nightmare (Magic 30th Anniversary) — $30.08
Nightmare (Fourth Edition (Foreign Black Border)) — $20.97
Cards in Similar Price Range
Magic: The Gathering cards priced near $1.14:
- Ugin, Eye of the Storms Art Card (1/54) (Gold-Stamped Signature) (Art Series: Tarkir: Dragonstorm) — $1.14
- Dismal Backwater [Foil] (Magic Tarkir: Dragonstorm) — $1.14
- Venser, Corpse Puppet (Magic Phyrexia: All Will Be One) — $1.14
- Alter Reality (Magic Torment) — $1.14
- Elder Arthur Maxson (Surge Foil) (Universes Beyond: Fallout) — $1.14
- Sling Gang Lieutenant (Magic Modern Horizons 3) — $1.14
- Bitter Triumph [JP Alternate Art] (Magic Secrets of Strixhaven Mystical Archive) — $1.14
- Quiet Purity [Foil] (Magic Champions of Kamigawa) — $1.14
Related Pages
- Nightmare Price Chart & History
- Cards Similar to Nightmare
- Nightmare Investment Analysis
- Nightmare Condition Prices (LP/MP/HP)
- Fifth Edition Set Price Guide
- Magic: The Gathering Hub
- Magic: The Gathering Price Guide
- Rare Magic: The Gathering Cards
- Most Expensive Magic: The Gathering Cards
- Best Cards Under $5
- Magic: The Gathering Market Movers Today
- Scan Your Cards
- AI Card Grading
- Grading ROI Calculator
- Card Value Checker
- Where to Sell Magic: The Gathering Cards
Frequently Asked Questions
How much is Nightmare from Fifth Edition worth?
Nightmare from Fifth Edition is currently worth $1.14 in 2026. Prices are updated daily from multiple sources.
How rare is Nightmare in Fifth Edition?
Nightmare is a Rare card from the Fifth Edition set in Magic: The Gathering.
Is Nightmare going up in value?
Nightmare has decreased 0.0% in the last 7 days and decreased 17.6% in 30 days. Current Guardian Estimate: $1.14.
Where can I buy Nightmare?
You can compare prices and buy Nightmare on TCGPlayer, eBay, and CardMarket. Guardian TCG tracks live prices from all three sources — current Guardian Estimate: $1.14.
Trending Right Now
- LeBron James [Essential Credentials Future 1/1] (2003 E-X) — $892835.94
- Mike Trout [Chrome Prospects Autographs Superfractors 1/1] (2009 Bowman Draft Picks & Prospects) — $1824003.80
- Stephen Curry [Rookie Patch Autograph (RPA) Century Gold /25] (2009 National Treasures) — $649505.00
- Shohei Ohtani [Clear] (2025 Topps) — $1250000.00
- Kobe Bryant [Refractor] (1996 Topps Chrome) — $1120158.20
- Babe Ruth [Red] (1933 Goudey) — $2496710.20
- Ty Cobb [Sweet Caporal 150/30 Portrait - Green] (1909 T206) — $830031.40
- Jim Thorpe [Football] (1933 Goudey Sport Kings) — $1432681.20
- Honus Wagner [Sweet Caporal 150/30] (1909 T206) — $4132718.20
- Michael Jordan [Emblems of Endorsement] (2003 Exquisite Collection) — $1084868.90
- Luka Doncic [Rookie Patch Autograph (RPA) Logoman 1/1] (2018 National Treasures) — $1947005.90
- Lionel Messi [Mega Cracks] (2004 Panini Sports) — $723020.90
- Yu-Gi-Oh! Card Prices
- Baseball Card Prices
- Basketball Card Prices
7-Day Top Movers
- Persian GX (Double Blaze) — $14.99 (+497.2% this week)
- Sol Ring (Commander: Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles) — $10.65 (+485.2% this week)
- Rayquaza EX (Dream Shine Collection) — $154.08 (+478.8% this week)
- M Gallade EX (Emerald Break) — $69.42 (+464.9% this week)
- Centiskorch VMAX (Explosive Walker) — $5.55 (+460.6% this week)
- Team Aqua's Kyogre EX (Pokemon Korean Double Crisis) — $493.29 (+448.7% this week)
- Eevee (Call of Legends) — $15.97 (+446.9% this week)
- Slugma (98) (Skyridge) — $99.99 (+437.3% this week)
How much is Nightmare from Fifth Edition worth?
Nightmare from Fifth Edition is currently worth $1.14 in 2026. Prices are updated daily from multiple sources.
How rare is Nightmare in Fifth Edition?
Nightmare is a Rare card from the Fifth Edition set in Magic: The Gathering.
Is Nightmare going up in value?
Nightmare has decreased 0.0% in the last 7 days and decreased 17.6% in 30 days. Current Guardian Estimate: $1.14.
Where can I buy Nightmare?
You can compare prices and buy Nightmare on TCGPlayer, eBay, and CardMarket. Guardian TCG tracks live prices from all three sources — current Guardian Estimate: $1.14.