| 1/10 | Mothman (Pin Club Cryptid Nation Mystery Collection) | Gold | $9.97 |
| 1/13 | Bigfoot (Pin Club Wilderness Mystery Collection) | Gold | $0.00 |
| 1/15 | Mothman (Pin Club Nightfall Mystery Collection 1st Edition) | Gold | $2.74 |
| 1/7 | Grays (Disclosure Pack Promos) | Gold | $20.00 |
| 14/165 | Ghosts of the Sloss Furnaces (Walmart Exclusive) | Gold | $0.82 |
| 17/165 | Glacial Demon (Walmart Exclusive) | Gold | $0.69 |
| 19/165 | Copenhagen Devil (Walmart Exclusive) | Gold | $0.89 |
| 1A/4 | Headless Horseman - 1A (Pin Club Nightfall Mystery Collection 1st Edition) | Gold | $24.99 |
| 1A/4 | Headless Horseman - 1A (Pin Club Nightfall Mystery Collection 2nd Wave) | Gold | $0.00 |
| 1A/5 | Bigfoot -1A (Pin Club Wilderness Mystery Collection) | Gold | $4.01 |
| 2/10 | Mothman (Bear Walker Longboards Promo with Redeemable Code) | Gold | $0.00 |
| 2/10 | Mothman (Bear Walker Longboards Promo) | Gold | $0.00 |
| 2/10 | Piasa Bird (Pin Club Cryptid Nation Mystery Collection) | Gold | $3.80 |
| 2/13 | Chibi Bigfoot (Pin Club Wilderness Mystery Collection) | Gold | $3.49 |
| 2/15 | Wendigo (Pin Club Nightfall Mystery Collection 1st Edition) | Gold | $2.06 |
| 2/2 | Headcaster Poker Night | Gold | $0.00 |
| 2/7 | UFO (Disclosure Pack Promos) | Gold | $0.00 |
| 2A/4 | Mothman - 2A (Pin Club Nightfall Mystery Collection 1st Edition) | Gold | $0.00 |
| 2A/4 | Mothman - 2A (Pin Club Nightfall Mystery Collection 2nd Wave) | Gold | $0.00 |
| 2A/5 | Chibi Bigfoot - 2A (Pin Club Wilderness Mystery Collection) | Gold | $12.00 |
| 3/10 | Babe The Blue Ox (Pin Club Cryptid Nation Mystery Collection) | Gold | $4.00 |
| 3/13 | Cumberland Dragon (Pin Club Wilderness Mystery Collection) | Gold | $2.34 |
| 3/15 | Headless Horseman (Pin Club Nightfall Mystery Collection 1st Edition) | Gold | $0.82 |
| 3/7 | Ominous Skies (Disclosure Pack Promos) | Gold | $1.00 |
| 3A/4 | Wendigo - 3A (Pin Club Nightfall Mystery Collection 1st Edition) | Gold | $0.00 |
| 3A/4 | Wendigo - 3A (Pin Club Nightfall Mystery Collection 2nd Wave) | Gold | $0.00 |
| 3A/5 | Cumberland Dragon - 3A (Pin Club Wilderness Mystery Collection) | Gold | $0.00 |
| 4/10 | Jersey Devil (Pin Club Cryptid Nation Mystery Collection) | Gold | $2.00 |
| 4/13 | Snipe (Pin Club Wilderness Mystery Collection) | Gold | $4.99 |
| 4/15 | Teakettler (Pin Club Nightfall Mystery Collection 1st Edition) | Gold | $0.72 |
| 4A/4 | Teakettler - 4A (Pin Club Nightfall Mystery Collection 1st Edition) | Gold | $0.00 |
| 4A/5 | Snipe - 4A (Pin Club Wilderness Mystery Collection) | Gold | $10.00 |
| 5/10 | Flatwoods Monster (Pin Club Cryptid Nation Mystery Collection) | Gold | $0.00 |
| 5/13 | Unicorn (Pin Club Wilderness Mystery Collection) | Gold | $0.00 |
| 5/7 | Disclosure Files (Disclosure Pack Promos) | Gold | $2.00 |
| 5/7 | Recovered Biologics (Disclosure Pack Promos) | Gold | $35.00 |
| 5A/5 | Unicorn - 5A (Pin Club Wilderness Mystery Collection) | Gold | $20.99 |
| 6/7 | Wreckage (Disclosure Pack Promos) | Gold | $2.00 |
| 7/10 | Bigfoot (Pin Club Cryptid Nation Mystery Collection) | Gold | $2.69 |
| 8/10 | Sinkhole Sam (Pin Club Cryptid Nation Mystery Collection) | Gold | $0.75 |
| 8/165 | Callopode (Walmart Exclusive) | Gold | $0.00 |
| P | Dinged Dingbelle | Gold | $0.00 |
| 2022 Pumpkin Carving Competition | Gold | $0.00 |
| Badtz-Maru (SDCC 2023) | Gold | $0.00 |
| Big Bird (LGS Promo) | Gold | $0.00 |
| Bigfoot (Gamer Supps Promo) | Gold | $0.00 |
| Billiwhack Monster (SDCC 2022) | Gold | $0.00 |
| Chibi Babe the Blue Ox (LGS Promo) | Gold | $4.49 |
| Chibi Wendigo (Native Big Box Blister Promo) | Gold | $1.21 |
| Chococat (SDCC 2023) | Gold | $0.00 |
| Chupacabra (PHD Exclusive) | Gold | $5.81 |
| Cinnamoroll (SDCC 2023) | Gold | $0.00 |
| Clash in the Cosmos (Ebay) | Gold | $0.00 |
| Cryptid Nation - First Edition | Gold | $0.00 |
| Cryptid Nation - Second Edition | Gold | $0.95 |
| Cumberland Dragon | Gold | $0.12 |
| Cumberland Spaceman (LGS Promo) | Gold | $0.00 |
| Dragon of Oconto Falls (1st Edition) | Gold | $0.56 |
| Earth Tower | Gold | $0.00 |
| Edgar Cayce (LGS Promo) | Gold | $0.00 |
| Father Sam, BBQ Revolutionary (Summer Promo) | Gold | $0.00 |
| Foo Fighters (UFO: First Edition Blister Promo) | Gold | $0.19 |
| Golden Haired Girl (LGS Promo) | Gold | $0.00 |
| Green Goblin | Gold | $60.00 |
| Hello Kitty (SDCC 2023) | Gold | $0.00 |
| Hopkinsville Goblin | Gold | $0.00 |
| Iowa Dragon (PHD Exclusive) | Gold | $0.00 |
| Jersey Devil | Gold | $0.33 |
| Join the Seance (NYCC 2022) | Gold | $4.00 |
| Keroppi (SDCC 2023) | Gold | $0.00 |
| Kuromi (Giveaway Booth) (NYCC 2023) | Gold | $0.00 |
| Kuromi (Jack-O-Lantern) (NYCC 2023) | Gold | $0.00 |
| Kuromi (Mothman Head) (NYCC 2023) | Gold | $0.00 |
| Kuromi (Photobooth Bench) (NYCC 2023) | Gold | $0.00 |
| Kuromi (Pink Hat) (NYCC 2023) | Gold | $0.00 |
| Kuromi (Purple Hat) (NYCC 2023) | Gold | $0.00 |
| Kuromi (SDCC 2023) | Gold | $0.00 |
| Kuromi (Shopping Bag) (NYCC 2023) | Gold | $0.00 |
| Kuromi's Cryptid Carnival Opening Celebration (NYCC 2023) | Gold | $0.00 |
| Mini T-Rex (UFO: First Edition Blister Promo) | Gold | $0.54 |
| Mishipeshu (LGS Promo) | Gold | $0.00 |
| Mothman | Gold | $8.58 |
| Mothman (Cryptid Nation: Kickstarter Edition Blister Promo) | Gold | $0.00 |
| Mothman (Cryptid Nation: Second Edition Blister Promo) | Gold | $0.52 |
| My Melody (NYCC 2023) | Gold | $0.00 |
| My Melody (SDCC 2023) | Gold | $0.00 |
| NYC King | Gold | $14.17 |
| Nightfall | Gold | $0.40 |
| Nightmarchers (LGS Promo) | Gold | $0.00 |
| Piasa Bird (Walmart Exclusive) | Gold | $0.59 |
| Pompompurin (SDCC 2023) | Gold | $0.00 |
| Raven Mocker (Native Big Box Blister Promo) | Gold | $1.27 |
| Rudy, Investment Sasquatch | Gold | $99.22 |
| Rudy, One Big Hairy Step | Gold | $15.00 |
| Rudy, Really Big Feet | Gold | $8.20 |
| Rudy, Totally Not a Timmy | Gold | $10.64 |
| Rudy, the Cave Painting | Gold | $26.88 |
| Rudy, the Hunchback of Jacksonville | Gold | $13.63 |
| Sam Sinclair (Kansas City Collect-A-Con 2023) | Gold | $26.99 |
| Sky Snake (LGS Promo) | Gold | $4.58 |
| Smokey Bear (1st Edition) | Gold | $3.50 |
| The Far Out Bunch (First Edition) | Gold | $10.00 |
| The Jewel of the Uktena (Native Big Box Blister Promo) | Gold | $0.99 |
| The Wild Ones (Pin Club Wilderness Mystery Collection) | Gold | $0.00 |
| UFO (UFO: First Edition Blister Promo) | Gold | $0.43 |
| UFO! (UFO: First Edition Spellbook Promo) | Gold | $0.24 |
| Wakinyan (UFO: First Edition Blister Promo) | Gold | $0.49 |
| White Screamer (LGS Promo) | Gold | $0.00 |
| Wilderness | Gold | $0.20 |