Cards Similar to Nightmare — Magic: The Gathering Alternatives (2026)

Nightmare from Magic International Edition is currently valued at $18.09. Browse 30 similar Magic: The Gathering cards by character, rarity, and price range.

Similar Cards

Kaito, Bane of Nightmares — Magic Duskmourn: House of Horror — $17.87
Rat Colony — Magic Secret Lair Drop — $18.09
Vault of Champions — Magic Commander Masters — $18.09
Murktide Regent — Magic Secret Lair Drop — $18.09
Birthing Pod — Magic Secret Lair 30th Anniversary — $18.08
Omniscience [Foil] — Magic Core Set 2013 — $18.10
Birds of Paradise — Magic 7th Edition — $18.08
Swamp — Magic Secret Lair Drop — $18.08
Phyrexian Metamorph [Foil] — Magic New Phyrexia — $18.08
Forest — Magic Beta — $18.08
Cranial Plating [Foil] — Magic Time Spiral Remastered — $18.10
Concordant Crossroads — Magic Chronicles — $18.10
Saffi Eriksdotter [Foil] — Magic Time Spiral — $18.10
All Will Be One — Magic Phyrexia: All Will Be One — $18.10
Blood for the Blood God! [Surge Foil] — Magic Warhammer 40,000 — $18.10
Counterbalance — Magic Secret Lair Drop — $18.07
Palantir of Orthanc — Magic Lord of the Rings — $18.11
Ponder [Rainbow Foil] — Magic Secret Lair Drop — $18.07
Yavimaya Coast [Foil] — Magic 9th Edition — $18.07
Wu Spy — Magic Portal Three Kingdoms — $18.11