Cards Similar to Island — Magic: The Gathering Alternatives (2026)

Island from Magic Alpha is currently valued at $48.45. Browse 30 similar Magic: The Gathering cards by character, rarity, and price range.

Similar Cards

Lure — Magic Alpha — $47.88
Karma — Magic Alpha — $49.16
Terror — Magic Alpha — $49.58
Dismember [Borderless Foil] — Magic Secret Lair Drop — $48.46
Commander 2019 Deck - Faceless Menace — Commander 2019 — $48.43
The Lord of the Rings: Tales of Middle-earth Commander Deck - Riders of Rohan — Commander: The Lord of the Rings: Tales of Middle-earth — $48.48
Secret Lair x FINAL FANTASY: Gilded Lotus - Rainbow Foil Edition (Japanese) — Secret Lair Drop Series — $48.49
Crucible of Worlds [Foil] — Magic Fifth Dawn — $48.49
Fangorn Forest [Foil] — Magic Lord of the Rings Commander — $48.40
Secret Lair Drop: Absolute Annihilation - Non-Foil Edition — Secret Lair Drop Series — $48.38
Undercity Sewers [Borderless Foil] — Magic Murders at Karlov Manor — $48.52
Secret Lair Drop: April Fools — Secret Lair Drop Series — $48.53
Ad Nauseam [JP Alternate Art] — Magic Secrets of Strixhaven Mystical Archive — $48.36
Nuka-Cola Vending Machine [Borderless Foil] — Magic Fallout — $48.54
Mycosynth Lattice [Foil] — Magic Battlebond — $48.55
Pili-Pala [Foil] — Magic Shadowmoor — $48.55
Chandra, Pyromaster — Magic Promo — $48.35
Champion's Helm — Magic Kaladesh Inventions — $48.56
We Want… A SHRUBBERY! - Three Visits [Foil] — Magic Secret Lair Drop — $48.34
Secret Lair Drop: Goblingram - Rainbow Foil Edition — Secret Lair Drop Series — $48.56