Cheapest Baseball Cards — Budget Picks Under $5 (May 2026)

6,040 Baseball cards under $5. Find affordable baseball cards to start or expand your collection. Prices updated May 2026.

Most Affordable Baseball Cards

1. Carlos Correa [True Photo] (2025 Topps, Unknown) — $0.01
2. Blood Omen (PAL Xbox, Unknown) — $0.01
3. Jose Ramirez / Aaron Judge / Brent Rooker [Holiday] (2025 Topps, Unknown) — $0.01
4. Anthony Rendon [Platinum] (2025 Topps, Unknown) — $0.01
5. Luis De Los Santos [Wood] (2025 Topps, Unknown) — $0.01
6. Michael Toglia [Aqua Foil] (2025 Topps, Unknown) — $0.07
7. Dylan Cease [Silver Cracked] (2025 Topps, Unknown) — $0.07
8. Kameron Misner [Easter Egg] (2025 Topps, Unknown) — $0.10
9. Pedro Leon [Platinum] (2025 Topps, Unknown) — $0.21
10. Eloy Jimenez [Pink Foil] (2025 Topps, Unknown) — $0.23
11. Blake Perkins [Silver Cracked] (2025 Topps, Unknown) — $0.25
12. Eloy Jimenez [Aqua Foil] (2025 Topps, Unknown) — $0.25
13. Eloy Jimenez [Rainbow Foil] (2025 Topps, Unknown) — $0.25
14. Amed Rosario [Silver Cracked] (2025 Topps, Unknown) — $0.25
15. Anthony Rendon [Holo Foil] (2025 Topps, Unknown) — $0.25
16. CJ Abrams [Topps Foil Pattern] (2025 Topps, Unknown) — $0.25
17. Daulton Varsho [Easter Egg] (2025 Topps, Unknown) — $0.25
18. Brenton Doyle [Silver Cracked] (2025 Topps, Unknown) — $0.25
19. Carlos Correa [Pink Diamante Foil] (2025 Topps, Unknown) — $0.25
20. Carlos Correa [Tin Variations] (2025 Topps, Unknown) — $0.25
21. Cedric Mullins [Silver Cracked] (2025 Topps, Unknown) — $0.25
22. Cristian Mena [Rainbow Foil] (2025 Topps, Unknown) — $0.25
23. Cristian Mena [Silver Cracked] (2025 Topps, Unknown) — $0.25
24. Carlos Correa [Pink Foil] (2025 Topps, Unknown) — $0.25
25. Amed Rosario [Aqua Foil] (2025 Topps, Unknown) — $0.25
26. Jose Ramirez / Aaron Judge / Brent Rooker [Silver Cracked] (2025 Topps, Unknown) — $0.25
27. Will Benson [Platinum] (2025 Topps, Unknown) — $0.25
28. Gavin Sheets [Holiday] (2025 Topps, Unknown) — $0.25
29. Lourdes Gurriel Jr. [Silver Cracked] (2025 Topps, Unknown) — $0.25
30. Miles Mikolas [Silver Cracked] (2025 Topps, Unknown) — $0.25

Frequently Asked Questions

What are the cheapest Baseball cards worth buying? The most affordable Baseball cards start at under $1. Many rare and popular cards can be found under $5, making them great entry points for new collectors.