Magic Shadows Over Innistrad Price Guide — Card Values & Prices (2026)

Complete Magic Shadows Over Innistrad price guide: 605 cards tracked, total set value $529.27. Prices last updated: May 4, 2026.

Magic Shadows Over Innistrad Market Snapshot

Total Set Value
$529.27
Average Card Price
$0.87
Lowest Priced Card
$0.01
Cards Tracked
605

How Guardian Calculates Magic Shadows Over Innistrad Prices

Guardian builds this set price guide from live raw card prices, graded estimates, recent sales, and outlier checks across supported marketplaces. The total set value is the sum of tracked singles with current market prices, while PSA columns show graded-card estimates when enough data is available.

Read the full Guardian Oracle pricing methodology.

Shortcuts

Track This Set

Add cards from Magic Shadows Over Innistrad to a Guardian collection to track completion, total set value, grading candidates, and cards worth selling.

Most Valuable Magic Shadows Over Innistrad Cards

#CardRarityRawPSA 9PSA 1030d
Fat PackUnknown$51.60N/AN/AN/A
Eerie Interlude [Foil]Unknown$12.69N/AN/AN/A
Relentless DeadUnknown$12.49N/AN/AN/A
Relentless Dead [Foil]Unknown$11.87N/AN/AN/A
Sorin, Grim Nemesis [Foil]Unknown$9.70N/AN/AN/A
Archangel Avacyn [Foil]Unknown$8.99N/AN/AN/A
The Gitrog Monster [Foil]Unknown$7.73N/AN/AN/A
Booster PackUnknown$6.74N/AN/AN/A
Diregraf Colossus [Foil]Unknown$6.66N/AN/AN/A
Essence Flux [Foil]Unknown$6.39N/AN/AN/A
107Diregraf ColossusUnknown$6.37N/AN/AN/A
81Rattlechains [Prerelease]Unknown$6.19N/AN/AN/A
Tamiyo's Journal [Foil]Unknown$6.16N/AN/AN/A
Eerie InterludeUnknown$6.00N/AN/AN/A
Nahiri, the Harbinger [Foil]Unknown$5.79N/AN/AN/A
Open the Armory [Foil]Unknown$5.64N/AN/AN/A
Anguished Unmaking [Foil]Unknown$5.62N/AN/AN/A
Eerie Interlude [Prerelease]Unknown$5.59N/AN/AN/A
Cryptolith Rite [Foil]Unknown$5.46N/AN/AN/A
Behind the Scenes [Foil]Unknown$5.05N/AN/AN/A
Cryptolith RiteUnknown$5.01N/AN/AN/A
Odric, Lunarch Marshal [Foil]Unknown$4.97N/AN/AN/A
Alms of the Vein [Foil]Unknown$4.94N/AN/AN/A
Ulvenwald Hydra [Foil]Unknown$4.79N/AN/AN/A
Behold the Beyond [Foil]Unknown$4.74N/AN/AN/A
Seasons Past [Foil]Unknown$4.58N/AN/AN/A
Westvale Abbey [Foil]Unknown$4.50N/AN/AN/A
Thalia's Lieutenant [Foil]Unknown$4.46N/AN/AN/A
Olivia, Mobilized for War [Foil]Unknown$4.42N/AN/AN/A
Fevered Visions [Foil]Unknown$4.12N/AN/AN/A
Sage of Ancient Lore [Foil]Unknown$3.98N/AN/AN/A
Sigarda, Heron's Grace [Foil]Unknown$3.98N/AN/AN/A
5Archangel Avacyn // Avacyn, the Purifier [Prerelease]Unknown$3.88N/AN/AN/A
58Engulf The Shore [Prerelease]Unknown$3.84N/AN/AN/A
Geier Reach Bandit [Foil]Unknown$3.59N/AN/AN/A
5Archangel AvacynUnknown$3.48N/AN/AN/A
281Westvale AbbeyUnknown$3.15N/AN/AN/A
Sorin, Grim NemesisUnknown$3.00N/AN/AN/A
Startled Awake [Foil]Unknown$2.87N/AN/AN/A
Topplegeist [Foil]Unknown$2.80N/AN/AN/A
Anguished UnmakingUnknown$2.76N/AN/AN/A
Open the ArmoryUnknown$2.75N/AN/AN/A
Indulgent Aristocrat [Foil]Unknown$2.74N/AN/AN/A
Stensia Masquerade [Foil]Unknown$2.73N/AN/AN/A
Always Watching [Foil]Unknown$2.72N/AN/AN/A
69Jace, Unraveler of Secrets [Foil]Unknown$2.71N/AN/AN/A
Traverse the Ulvenwald [Foil]Unknown$2.66N/AN/AN/A
Pore Over the Pages [Foil]Unknown$2.64N/AN/AN/A
Insolent Neonate [Foil]Unknown$2.62N/AN/AN/A
Second Harvest [Foil]Unknown$2.60N/AN/AN/A
Cult of the Waxing Moon [Foil]Unknown$2.47N/AN/AN/A
Hermit of the Natterknolls [Foil]Unknown$2.37N/AN/AN/A
Trail of Evidence [Foil]Unknown$2.33N/AN/AN/A
245The Gitrog MonsterUnknown$2.31N/AN/AN/A
Tireless Tracker [Foil]Unknown$2.19N/AN/AN/A
Erdwal Illuminator [Foil]Unknown$2.17N/AN/AN/A
Engulf the Shore [Foil]Unknown$2.10N/AN/AN/A
Seasons PastUnknown$2.09N/AN/AN/A
Tamiyo's JournalUnknown$2.07N/AN/AN/A
Second HarvestUnknown$2.06N/AN/AN/A
Brain in a Jar [Foil]Unknown$2.00N/AN/AN/A
12Clue [Token]Unknown$1.96N/AN/AN/A
Manic Scribe [Foil]Unknown$1.85N/AN/AN/A
92Thing in the Ice [Foil]Unknown$1.82N/AN/AN/A
Fevered VisionsUnknown$1.79N/AN/AN/A
Moonlight Hunt [Foil]Unknown$1.75N/AN/AN/A
Forgotten Creation [Foil]Unknown$1.71N/AN/AN/A
Choked Estuary [Foil]Unknown$1.70N/AN/AN/A
Crawling Sensation [Foil]Unknown$1.63N/AN/AN/A
Descend upon the Sinful [Foil]Unknown$1.58N/AN/AN/A
Sin Prodder [Foil]Unknown$1.56N/AN/AN/A
Drownyard Temple [Foil]Unknown$1.55N/AN/AN/A
Foreboding Ruins [Foil]Unknown$1.50N/AN/AN/A
Essence FluxUnknown$1.45N/AN/AN/A
2Angel Of Deliverance [Pre-Release]Unknown$1.44N/AN/AN/A
Silverfur Partisan [Foil]Unknown$1.43N/AN/AN/A
Fortified Village [Foil]Unknown$1.42N/AN/AN/A
Skeleton Key [Foil]Unknown$1.41N/AN/AN/A
157Flameblade Angel [Foil Promo]Unknown$1.40N/AN/AN/A
Howlpack Resurgence [Foil]Unknown$1.39N/AN/AN/A
Goldnight Castigator [Foil]Unknown$1.38N/AN/AN/A
Accursed Witch [Foil]Unknown$1.38N/AN/AN/A
69Jace, Unraveler of SecretsUnknown$1.37N/AN/AN/A
Haunted Cloak [Foil]Unknown$1.36N/AN/AN/A
Game Trail [Foil]Unknown$1.36N/AN/AN/A
Village Messenger [Foil]Unknown$1.29N/AN/AN/A
Duskwatch Recruiter [Foil]Unknown$1.29N/AN/AN/A
296ForestUnknown$1.26N/AN/AN/A
Olivia's Bloodsworn [Foil]Unknown$1.25N/AN/AN/A
14Clue [Token]Unknown$1.25N/AN/AN/A
13Clue [Token]Unknown$1.25N/AN/AN/A
286IslandUnknown$1.19N/AN/AN/A
Behold the BeyondUnknown$1.19N/AN/AN/A
Asylum Visitor [Foil]Unknown$1.17N/AN/AN/A
Hanweir Militia Captain [Foil]Unknown$1.16N/AN/AN/A
Burn from Within [Foil]Unknown$1.15N/AN/AN/A
11Clue [Token]Unknown$1.15N/AN/AN/A
283PlainsUnknown$1.15N/AN/AN/A
Breakneck Rider [Foil]Unknown$1.13N/AN/AN/A
Pieces of the Puzzle [Foil]Unknown$1.10N/AN/AN/A

Cheapest Magic Shadows Over Innistrad Cards

Card#RarityRaw PricePSA 10
Dauntless CatharUnknown$0.01N/A
Hulking Devil [Foil]Unknown$0.01N/A
Sleep Paralysis [Foil]Unknown$0.01N/A
Gloomwidow [Foil]Unknown$0.01N/A
Humble the Brute [Foil]Unknown$0.01N/A
Explosive Apparatus [Foil]Unknown$0.01N/A
Militant InquisitorUnknown$0.02N/A
Silent ObserverUnknown$0.02N/A
Reckless Scholar [Foil]Unknown$0.02N/A
Rabid Bite223Unknown$0.02N/A
Reckless ScholarUnknown$0.02N/A
Epitaph Golem [Foil]Unknown$0.02N/A
Nagging ThoughtsUnknown$0.02N/A
Aberrant Researcher [Foil]Unknown$0.02N/A
Intrepid Provisioner213Unknown$0.02N/A
Press for Answers80Unknown$0.02N/A
Catalog [Foil]Unknown$0.02N/A
Inspiring CaptainUnknown$0.02N/A
GloomwidowUnknown$0.03N/A
Moldgraf ScavengerUnknown$0.03N/A

Magic Shadows Over Innistrad Checklist by Number

#CardRaw PricePSA 10
Fat Pack$51.60N/A
Eerie Interlude [Foil]$12.69N/A
Relentless Dead$12.49N/A
Relentless Dead [Foil]$11.87N/A
Sorin, Grim Nemesis [Foil]$9.70N/A
Archangel Avacyn [Foil]$8.99N/A
The Gitrog Monster [Foil]$7.73N/A
Booster Pack$6.74N/A
Diregraf Colossus [Foil]$6.66N/A
Essence Flux [Foil]$6.39N/A
Tamiyo's Journal [Foil]$6.16N/A
Eerie Interlude$6.00N/A
Nahiri, the Harbinger [Foil]$5.79N/A
Open the Armory [Foil]$5.64N/A
Anguished Unmaking [Foil]$5.62N/A
Eerie Interlude [Prerelease]$5.59N/A
Cryptolith Rite [Foil]$5.46N/A
Behind the Scenes [Foil]$5.05N/A
Cryptolith Rite$5.01N/A
Odric, Lunarch Marshal [Foil]$4.97N/A
Alms of the Vein [Foil]$4.94N/A
Ulvenwald Hydra [Foil]$4.79N/A
Behold the Beyond [Foil]$4.74N/A
Seasons Past [Foil]$4.58N/A
Westvale Abbey [Foil]$4.50N/A
Thalia's Lieutenant [Foil]$4.46N/A
Olivia, Mobilized for War [Foil]$4.42N/A
Fevered Visions [Foil]$4.12N/A
Sage of Ancient Lore [Foil]$3.98N/A
Sigarda, Heron's Grace [Foil]$3.98N/A
Geier Reach Bandit [Foil]$3.59N/A
Sorin, Grim Nemesis$3.00N/A
Startled Awake [Foil]$2.87N/A
Topplegeist [Foil]$2.80N/A
Anguished Unmaking$2.76N/A
Open the Armory$2.75N/A
Indulgent Aristocrat [Foil]$2.74N/A
Stensia Masquerade [Foil]$2.73N/A
Always Watching [Foil]$2.72N/A
Traverse the Ulvenwald [Foil]$2.66N/A
Pore Over the Pages [Foil]$2.64N/A
Insolent Neonate [Foil]$2.62N/A
Second Harvest [Foil]$2.60N/A
Cult of the Waxing Moon [Foil]$2.47N/A
Hermit of the Natterknolls [Foil]$2.37N/A
Trail of Evidence [Foil]$2.33N/A
Tireless Tracker [Foil]$2.19N/A
Erdwal Illuminator [Foil]$2.17N/A
Engulf the Shore [Foil]$2.10N/A
Seasons Past$2.09N/A

Related Pages

How many cards are in Magic Shadows Over Innistrad?

Magic Shadows Over Innistrad has 605 cards tracked with a total set value of $529.27. Most valuable: Fat Pack ($51.60).

What is the most expensive card in Magic Shadows Over Innistrad?

The most expensive Magic Shadows Over Innistrad card is Fat Pack at $51.60. The set has 605 cards with a total value of $529.27.

Is Magic Shadows Over Innistrad a good investment?

Magic Shadows Over Innistrad contains 605 priced cards worth $529.27 total. The most expensive card is Fat Pack at $51.60. Check our Magic: The Gathering market movers for current trends.

When was Magic Shadows Over Innistrad price data last updated?

Magic Shadows Over Innistrad prices were last updated May 4, 2026. Guardian TCG refreshes card data daily from TCGPlayer, eBay, and CardMarket.

Trending Right Now

7-Day Top Movers