Cards Similar to Nightmare — Magic: The Gathering Alternatives (2026)

Nightmare from Welcome Deck 2016 is currently valued at $0.13. Browse 30 similar Magic: The Gathering cards by character, rarity, and price range.

Similar Cards

Urza's Rage — The List — $0.13
Fool's Tome — The List — $0.13
Magus of the Arena — Commander 2013 — $0.13
Menacing Ogre — Planechase — $0.13
Dark Hatchling — Commander Anthology Volume II — $0.13
Learned Learner (No PW Symbol) — Mystery Booster: Convention Edition Exclusives — $0.13
Carnival Barker — Unfinity — $0.13
Subira, Tulzidi Caravanner — The List Reprints — $0.13
Search the Premises — Commander: Murders at Karlov Manor — $0.13
Temple of Enlightenment — Duskmourn: House of Horror Commander — $0.13
True Identity (Extended Art) — Commander: Murders at Karlov Manor — $0.13
Bedlam Reveler — Innistrad Remastered — $0.13
Disaster Radius — Commander — $0.13
Sage-Eye Avengers — Fate Reforged — $0.13
Temporal Firestorm — Dominaria United — $0.13
Yet Another Aether Vortex — Unsanctioned — $0.13
Hoofprints of the Stag — Commander: Lorwyn Eclipsed — $0.13
Spinal Embrace — Commander 2013 — $0.13
Kjeldoran Dead — Ice Age — $0.13
Nephalia Smuggler — Duel Decks: Blessed vs. Cursed — $0.13

Groudon (Paradox Rift) — $117.30 (+68900.0% this week)
Team Rocket's Mewtwo ex (Destined Rivals) — $542.69 (+45890.7% this week)
Mega Gardevoir ex (Mega Evolution) — $200.33 (+31698.4% this week)
Samurott (White Flare) — $43.29 (+30821.4% this week)
Ethan's Ho-Oh ex (Destined Rivals) — $176.04 (+23689.2% this week)
Baxcalibur (Paldea Evolved) — $29.95 (+17517.7% this week)
Mega Venusaur ex (Mega Evolution) — $153.30 (+17320.5% this week)
Milotic ex (Surging Sparks) — $125.27 (+16382.9% this week)
Gardevoir ex (Scarlet & Violet) — $84.87 (+10508.8% this week)
Zeraora (Stellar Crown) — $11.59 (+10436.4% this week)
Mega Charizard X ex (Phantasmal Flames) — $373.56 (+9679.1% this week)
Mega Absol ex (Mega Evolution) — $67.79 (+9584.3% this week)
Grovyle (Emerald) — $1.04 (+9410.9% this week)
Tapu Bulu (Shrouded Fable) — $7.46 (+9225.0% this week)
Iron Moth (Paradox Rift) — $6.98 (+8625.0% this week)