Cards Similar to Nightmare (CE) — Magic: The Gathering Alternatives (2026)

Nightmare (CE) from Collector's Edition is currently valued at $15.54. Browse 30 similar Magic: The Gathering cards by character, rarity, and price range.

Similar Cards

Nightmare (CE) — Collector's Edition — $15.54
Manabarbs (CE) — Collector's Edition — $15.50
Gloom (CE) — Collector's Edition — $15.47
Two-Headed Giant of Foriys (CE) — Collector's Edition — $15.62
Juggernaut (CE) — Collector's Edition — $15.79
Aura Fracture — Prophecy — $15.56
Gamble (Retro Frame) — Dominaria Remastered — $15.50
Leonin Shikari (Italian) - "Shikari Leonid" — Magic Encyclopedia 2005 (Salvat/Hachette) — $15.50
Myr Token (MRD) — Magic Player Rewards — $15.50
Paralyze (Retro Frame) — 30th Anniversary Edition — $15.49
Tranquility (Retro Frame) — 30th Anniversary Edition — $15.61
The Very Soil Shall Shake (Archenemy) — Oversize Cards — $15.65
Dragon Token — Unique and Miscellaneous Promos — $15.65
The Very Soil Shall Shake (Archenemy) — Oversize Cards — $15.65
Clockspinning (Surge Foil) — Universes Beyond: Doctor Who — $15.67
Jump (Retro Frame) — 30th Anniversary Edition — $15.39
Evolving Wilds (Surge Foil) — Universes Beyond: Doctor Who — $15.71
Horizon of Progress (Extended Art) (Ripple Foil) — Commander: Modern Horizons 3 — $15.73
Farmstead — 30th Anniversary Edition — $15.75
Shatter — Beta Edition — $15.29